Home NFL Jalen Hurts has the wins and awards, so why is he being...

Jalen Hurts has the wins and awards, so why is he being called overrated?

0
Quarterback Jalen Hurts
Brad McPherson/Shutterstock.com 1634214367
Jalen Hurts attempts to throw football

Jalen Hurts ranks No. 3 on unwanted list

Jalen Alexander Hurts, quarterback for the Philadelphia Eagles, ranked No. 3 on FanSided’s 2026 list of the NFL’s most overrated players. The placement was based on ballots submitted by division site experts.

FanSided used a points system to combine those rankings into one order. Hurts received 13 points and three first-place votes, placing behind quarterbacks Bo Nix and Caleb Williams in the final results.

Jalen Hurts looks onto the field

Jalen Hurts ranking came from expert ballots

FanSided asked NFL division site experts to select their top three overrated players. The publication assigned points to those choices, creating a leaguewide ranking based on staff opinion rather than an NFL evaluation.

Hurts finished third with 13 points and three first-place votes. Bo Nix ranked first with 22 points, while Caleb Williams placed second with 16, confirming that quarterbacks occupied the top three positions.

Quarterback Jalen Hurts walks onto the field with children from the Boys and Girls Club prior to the 2020 Reese's Senior Bowl

Jalen Hurts owns a 56-22 starting record

Since becoming Philadelphia’s full-time starter in 2021, Jalen Hurts has recorded one of the NFL’s strongest regular-season winning records. Through the 2025 season, Hurts posted 56 regular-season wins in 78 starts.

From 2021 through 2025, Josh Allen recorded 60 regular-season wins and Patrick Mahomes recorded 57. Hurts finished with 56 victories, while his regular-season winning percentage during that span ranked among the league’s best.

The Vince Lombardi Trophy

Jalen Hurts has started two Super Bowls

Jalen Hurts has started two Super Bowls for Philadelphia. He first faced Kansas City in Super Bowl LVII after the 2022 season and returned two years later for Super Bowl LIX after the 2024 season.

The Eagles defeated the Chiefs 40-22 in Super Bowl LIX on February 9, 2025, earning Philadelphia its second Super Bowl championship.

Scrabble blocks spelling out the word "MVP"

Jalen Hurts earned Super Bowl LIX MVP

Hurts earned Super Bowl LIX Most Valuable Player after producing 293 total yards and three total touchdowns. He completed 17 of 22 passes for 221 yards, threw 2 touchdown passes, and added 72 rushing yards and 1 rushing touchdown against Kansas City.

His 72 rushing yards set a Super Bowl record for quarterbacks, breaking his previous mark of 70 rushing yards from Super Bowl LVII.

An American football player standing on knee on green grass and holding ball against white smoke

Jalen Hurts finished second for 2022 MVP

Hurts finished second in voting for the 2022 Associated Press NFL Most Valuable Player award. Patrick Mahomes received 490 points and 48 first-place votes, while Hurts collected 193 points and one first-place selection.

During that regular season, Hurts completed 66.5% of his passes for 3,701 yards and 22 touchdowns. He also recorded 760 rushing yards and 13 scores on the ground across 15 games.

NFL football on the field

Jalen Hurts produced across four seasons

From 2022 through 2025, Hurts recorded 13,686 passing yards, 88 passing touchdowns, and a 97.5 passer rating. His completion rate reached 66.2% across 63 regular-season games for Philadelphia during that span.

Those four seasons showed consistent passing production across changing offensive systems. The totals covered campaigns in which Hurts remained Philadelphia’s starter while completing nearly two-thirds of his attempts during the combined period.

Closeup of American football on field

Jalen Hurts set a rushing record in 2023

Hurts finished the 2023 regular season with 605 rushing yards and 15 touchdowns. That total matched Josh Allen for the most quarterback rushing scores in the NFL during that year.

Across the four seasons from 2022 through 2025, Hurts produced 50 rushing touchdowns. The 2023 total established an NFL single-season quarterback record before Allen finished that same campaign with an equal mark.

Quarterback Jalen Hurts

Jalen Hurts posted solid 2025 numbers

In 2025, Hurts threw for 3,224 yards, completed 64.8% of his attempts, recorded 25 touchdown passes against six interceptions, and finished with a 98.5 passer rating across 16 regular-season starts.

He also ran for 421 yards and eight touchdowns during that campaign. Philadelphia finished 24th in total offense and 19th in scoring, providing measurable context for the unit’s performance throughout the season.

Fun fact: Away from football, Hurts keeps a journal, loves old-school R&B, and reportedly took over his father’s crawfish-cooking duties. The stoic quarterback apparently has a kitchen side.

Coach logo on a black shirt

Jalen Hurts gets another coordinator

Sean Mannion replaced Kevin Patullo after Philadelphia’s 2025 offensive decline. Mannion previously coached Green Bay’s quarterbacks and entered the Eagles’ job as a first-time NFL play caller for the 2026 season.

The change gave Hurts his sixth offensive coordinator and seventh play caller in seven NFL seasons. Mannion has blended familiar Philadelphia concepts with new terminology and schematic elements during the installation process.

Superbowl stadium

Jalen Hurts owns major individual honors

Hurts has earned three Pro Bowl selections and a Super Bowl Most Valuable Player award. His career also includes multiple postseason runs, substantial rushing production, and one second-place finish in NFL MVP voting.

Those honors sit alongside his starting record and championship experience. Each accomplishment comes from an official result, statistical record, or award process rather than the opinion-based voting system behind the latest FanSided ranking.

Jalen Hurts addresses media during pre-announcement press conference

Jalen Hurts debate includes roster strength

FanSided’s ranking cited Philadelphia’s strong offensive line, skilled teammates, defense, and team success when evaluating Hurts. Those factors formed part of the reasoning behind his No. 3 placement on the list.

Hurts’ individual statistics and awards remain separate, recorded measures of his performance. The distinction allows the supporting-cast argument and his personal production to remain different parts of the discussion surrounding the ranking.

Tom Brady’s retirement might have ended differently if NFL rules had allowed another comeback. Curious what blocked his potential return? Dive into Brady’s explanation and the league restriction that closed the door.

Quarterback Jalen Hurts

Jalen Hurts enters 2026 with proven totals

Hurts entered 2026 with 17,891 career passing yards, 110 passing touchdowns, and 63 rushing scores across six regular seasons. Those figures establish his statistical record before beginning a seventh NFL campaign.

Mannion said Philadelphia would continue using its short-yardage quarterback push while introducing new schematic elements. The decision keeps one familiar feature for Hurts as the Eagles adjust other parts of their 2026 offense.

Aaron Rodgers’ hoped-for return to Green Bay will not happen under the NFL schedule. Curious what kept the Packers homecoming off the calendar? Dive into the scheduling details behind the missed reunion.

Jalen Hurts has the wins, awards, and statistics, yet some experts still call him overrated. Do you think the criticism is fair or overstated? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.

Read More From This Brand: