The Dallas Cowboys are facing renewed questions about their coaching decisions as another difficult start exposes problems that continue to frustrate the franchise. Owner and general manager Jerry Jones moved on from Mike McCarthy after the 2024 season, choosing Brian Schottenheimer to lead the team into a new era.
That decision was supposed to bring fresh momentum while preserving familiarity with the existing roster. However, Dallas has struggled to find consistent success under its new leadership, particularly on defense.
The Cowboys’ latest problems have revived discussion about whether replacing McCarthy addressed the organization’s biggest weaknesses. Jones now faces scrutiny over a transition that has yet to deliver the sustained progress Dallas needs.
Why McCarthy’s departure is being questioned again
McCarthy’s exit followed a disappointing 2024 campaign in which Dallas finished 7-10 and missed the playoffs. Injuries affected the roster, including quarterback Dak Prescott, while defensive issues and inconsistent performances contributed to the disappointing finish.
The Cowboys had also suffered an embarrassing 48-32 home playoff loss to the Green Bay Packers following the 2023 season. That defeat intensified criticism of McCarthy, whose teams repeatedly struggled to advance deep into the postseason despite strong regular-season records.
Jones ultimately allowed McCarthy’s contract to expire rather than bringing him back for another season. The decision created an opportunity for change, but subsequent struggles have complicated the argument that a coaching replacement alone could solve Dallas’ underlying problems.
McCarthy’s regular-season success remains part of the debate
McCarthy’s Dallas tenure included three consecutive 12-win regular seasons from 2021 through 2023. The Cowboys reached the playoffs each year during that stretch, establishing a level of regular-season consistency that became harder to maintain in 2024.
His overall record also compared favorably with the franchise’s historical coaching results. However, the postseason remained the defining weakness of his tenure, with Dallas winning only one playoff game under McCarthy before missing the playoffs in his final season.
That contrast explains why opinions about McCarthy remain divided. His supporters can point to sustained winning seasons, while critics can reasonably argue that those results never translated into a conference championship appearance or a Super Bowl run.
The Cowboys’ defensive problems have become impossible to ignore
Dallas’ struggles have extended beyond the original coaching transition. The 2025 defense performed poorly under coordinator Matt Eberflus, and the organization subsequently moved on from him rather than continuing with the same defensive leadership.
The problems have persisted in 2026 under defensive coordinator Christian Parker. Through 5 games, Dallas ranked 31st in total yards allowed and last in opponents’ passer rating, highlighting the defense’s continuing difficulties.
The Cowboys fell to 2-3 following their October 8 loss to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. On October 12, Dallas added veteran coach Mike Pettine as a senior defensive assistant to provide additional experience and support for its struggling defense.
Jones is now confronting the limits of coaching changes
The latest defensive adjustment illustrates the difficulty of fixing a team through coaching changes alone. Dallas has moved from McCarthy to Schottenheimer and replaced defensive coordinators, yet the defense remains a major source of concern.
Jones has defended Parker amid criticism, while the addition of Pettine offers the coaching staff another experienced voice. Pettine has worked with both Parker and Schottenheimer during previous NFL assignments, giving him established relationships within the current staff.
Those connections could help with communication and implementation, but a staff addition cannot immediately resolve every personnel or execution problem. Dallas still needs improved tackling, stronger defensive consistency, and more effective disruption of opposing offenses to turn its season around.
McCarthy’s record does not make the alternative obvious
The current situation has reopened debate about whether retaining McCarthy would have produced a better outcome. His regular-season record provides a credible basis for that argument, particularly when compared with Dallas’ difficulties since the coaching change.
However, the comparison has important limits. McCarthy’s final season ended with a losing record, and his teams repeatedly fell short in the playoffs, giving Jones legitimate reasons to consider a different direction.
There is also no way to establish how McCarthy would have handled the subsequent roster changes, injuries or defensive personnel decisions. The available results demonstrate that Dallas has struggled after his departure, not that keeping him would necessarily have prevented those problems.
Fun fact: Before becoming an NFL head coach, Mike McCarthy worked nights in a tollbooth on the Pennsylvania Turnpike while serving as an assistant coach at the University of Pittsburgh.
What the scrutiny means for Jerry Jones
As owner and general manager, Jones has final responsibility for the Cowboys’ coaching appointments and broader football decisions. That authority situates the McCarthy transition within a broader discussion of how the organization identifies problems and chooses solutions.
Schottenheimer’s offense showed considerable promise during the 2025 season, even as the defense struggled, suggesting that the coaching change has not been unsuccessful in every respect. The imbalance between offensive production and defensive performance has nevertheless prevented Dallas from building a consistently competitive team.
The immediate challenge is improving the defense while keeping the offense productive. If those changes fail to produce better results, scrutiny of Jones’ original decision will likely intensify, especially because the organization chose continuity in its head-coaching search rather than bringing in an outside leader.
Dallas’ current struggles do not prove McCarthy should have stayed. They do show that moving on from him did not automatically solve the franchise’s deeper problems, leaving Jones accountable for whether his latest coaching decisions can finally deliver the results the Cowboys have been pursuing.
TL;DR
- Jerry Jones moved on from Mike McCarthy after Dallas finished 7-10 in 2024 and missed the playoffs.
- McCarthy’s 3 consecutive 12-win seasons remain a significant part of the debate over his departure.
- Dallas’ defensive struggles continued under Matt Eberflus in 2025 and Christian Parker in 2026.
- The Cowboys added Mike Pettine as a senior defensive assistant on October 12, 2026, following a 2-3 start.
- Dallas’ current difficulties have revived questions about Jones’ coaching decisions, although they do not prove retaining McCarthy would have produced better results.
Read More From This Brand:
- Stephen A. Smith faces public criticism from ESPN coworkers over comments
- Patrick Mahomes’ latest ranking reveals why the Chiefs remain a serious threat
- Aaron Rodgers and Mike McCarthy address heated sideline exchange during Steelers’ loss
This article was made with AI assistance and human editing.
