Five teams are already circling A.J. Minter as he hits the open market, according to MLB Trade Rumors. This activity proves that teams still want a reliable arm, even after a rough 2026 season. For the second time in his career, Minter entered free agency following the conclusion of his two-year, $22MM contract with the Mets. He missed a full year of play due to lat surgery in early May 2025 before finally returning on May 26.
The Numbers Tell A Mixed Story
Minter posted a 2.56 ERA over 45 2/3 innings in 2026, but the details raise red flags. His strikeout percentage fell to 22%, a career worst, compared to the 29.4% average maintained from 2017 to 2025. The four-seamer velocity dropped to 93.5mph in 2026, down from a 94.5mph average in the prior two years. The drop in four-seamer velocity forced him to rely more on his cutter and led to nine home runs allowed. He gave up only 27 homers in his previous nine MLB seasons combined, so this jump is a major concern.
Why The Bidding War Still Happens
Despite the dip in strikeout numbers, Minter remains a top target for clubs needing left-handed pitching. MLB Trade Rumors notes that his walk rate was a career best at 4.3%, well below his 8.6% career average. His solid postseason track record includes a World Series ring won with the 2021 Braves. The Athletics had the worst bullpen ERA in baseball at 5.43 in 2026, while the Royals and Nationals ranked next with 5.07 and 4.99. Either relief corps would receive a huge upgrade from Minter, and his age-33 season might witness a full return to form.
Even though there is a need, Washington reportedly does not plan to spend much on its bullpen expenditures. Kansas City doesn’t spend much in general, which might limit how far they go in the bidding. Minter, born in Tyler, Texas, may not be the pitcher he once was, but is still proving to be a hot commodity.
