Former WNBA players spark controversy with Sophie Cunningham foul comments

More Stories

Sophie Cunningham during her time in Phoenix Mercury on the court

Sophie Cunningham draws foul comments

An October 11 report linked former Women’s National Basketball Association (WNBA) players Sydney Colson and Theresa Plaisance to remarks about hard fouls against Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham during games.

Neither Colson nor Plaisance appeared on a WNBA roster during the 2026 season. Their reported discussion followed earlier commentary about Cunningham’s basketball role and Indiana’s plans for the next season.

Full basketball hall on a league game night

Comments mentioned two scoring situations

The October 11 account identified transition three-point attempts and layups as the situations mentioned in the reported comments. Those opportunities occur as an offense quickly moves toward a potential basket.

The article summarized the suggestions without publishing the complete exchange between the two speakers. Its description did not establish that an opponent planned to follow the proposed approach in a game.

Basketball match in action

Sydney Colson has two WNBA championships

Sydney Colson played for Indiana during the 2025 season alongside Sophie Cunningham. The guard entered the WNBA as the 16th overall selection in the 2011 draft after attending Texas A&M.

Colson won championship titles with the Las Vegas Aces in 2022 and 2023. Her league profile lists a height of 5 feet, 8 inches and 11 years of WNBA experience.

Close-up of a basketball player dribbling the ball

Theresa Plaisance played 9 WNBA seasons

Theresa Plaisance joined the WNBA after Louisiana State University, with Tulsa selecting her 27th overall in the 2014 draft. The forward later won the 2022 championship title with Las Vegas.

Plaisance stands 6 feet, 5 inches and has 9 seasons of league experience. Her career averages were 4.5 points, 3.0 rebounds, and 0.7 assists per game across regular WNBA appearances.

Referee holding a basketball during a game

DiJonai Carrington was ejected in Chicago

Chicago Sky guard DiJonai Carrington received a Flagrant 2 foul against Sophie Cunningham during a first-quarter transition layup attempt on August 8, 2026. Officials reviewed the contact and ejected her.

The Indiana Fever won 90-86 at United Center. Kelsey Mitchell scored 27 points and set a WNBA single-season record with 16 consecutive games scoring at least 20 points during 2026.

Athlete experiencing a fresh injury

Sydney Colson missed time after knee injury

Sydney Colson suffered a torn left knee ligament during Indiana’s August 7, 2025, game against Phoenix. The Fever ruled her out for the rest of that season the following day.

Indiana also lost guard Aari McDonald to a right foot injury during the same period. The team subsequently added Odyssey Sims under a hardship contract to address its depleted backcourt.

Fans at a sold out basketball stadium

Sydney Colson questioned Indiana management

Sydney Colson discussed fan conduct during an October episode of the Unsupervised with Syd & TP podcast. The former Fever guard questioned how Indiana’s leaders responded to players’ complaints.

General manager Amber Cox had rejected broad allegations about the team’s supporters. Colson disagreed with that assessment, clarifying that her concerns did not apply to every individual attending Fever games.

Basketball with embossed WNBA text

WNBA rules distinguish two flagrant fouls

The WNBA’s official 2026 rulebook defines Flagrant 1 as unnecessary contact and Flagrant 2 as unnecessary and excessive contact. Officials must use instant replay to confirm either classification during games.

Both violations award the opposing team two free throws and possession. A Flagrant 2 carries mandatory ejection and the WNBA commissioner may impose further discipline, including a fine or suspension.

Sophie Cunningham in action

Sophie Cunningham recovered from knee injury

Sophie Cunningham sustained a torn ligament in her right knee during Indiana’s August 17, 2025, game against Connecticut. The injury ended her first Fever season after 30 appearances that year.

Cunningham averaged 8.6 points and 3.5 rebounds during that campaign. She also converted 43.2% of three-point attempts, ranking third among WNBA players in three-point accuracy during the 2025 regular season.

Woman working on laptop

Candace Buckner urged Indiana to part ways

The Athletic columnist Candace Buckner argued on October 6, 2026, that the Fever should part with Sophie Cunningham. Her column questioned the attention surrounding the guard and teammate Caitlin Clark.

Buckner also discussed Cunningham’s future on the October 8 episode of No Offseason, a women’s basketball podcast. The program examined Indiana’s supporting cast and roster choices around star guard Clark

Fun fact: Sophie Cunningham once revealed that she likes ranch dressing on spaghetti. The unusual combination left plenty of WNBA fans questioning her taste in food.

Sophie Cunningham in action

Sophie Cunningham answered public criticism

Sophie Cunningham responded to Buckner’s column on the No Hesitation podcast alongside trainer Drew Hanlen. In comments covered October 10, she rejected the suggestion that critics defined her basketball value.

Cunningham said her contributions extended beyond the stat sheet, including elements that scoring totals overlook. She questioned whether some critics had enough basketball experience to evaluate her performance fairly.

Sophie Cunningham in action during the basketball game

Sophie Cunningham made 41.9% of threes

Sophie Cunningham appeared in 43 WNBA regular-season games for Indiana in 2026. She averaged 7.9 points, 2.3 rebounds, and 1.2 assists while starting three of those contests for the Fever.

Cunningham converted 41.9% of her three-point attempts and 46% of all field-goal attempts. She finished with 338 points, 97 rebounds, and 52 assists during the 2026 regular season for Indiana.

For more on Indiana’s matchup with Las Vegas, check out why Candace Parker offered blunt on-air criticism of Caitlin Clark against the Aces.

Top-shot of a contract above piles of money

Indiana faces a decision on Cunningham

The Indiana Fever finished 2026 with a 28-16 record and entered the WNBA playoffs as the sixth seed. Las Vegas ended the run on October 1, winning Game 3 94-83.

Cunningham signed a one-year agreement with Indiana in April 2026, leaving her eligible for unrestricted free agency. The team had not announced a new contract or destination for the guard.

Sophie Cunningham has also raised concerns about officiating during a key Fever game. Explore how a failed challenge led her to question the referees’ decision.

Should former WNBA players face criticism for their comments about hard fouls against Sophie Cunningham, or is this simply part of basketball debate? Let us know what you think and share your thoughts in the comments below!

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.

Read More From This Brand:

Add Gameday Chatter as a preferred source on Google

Andy Mailhot
Andy Mailhot
Andy was born in Rhode Island and raised in Atlanta, Georgia. He grew up a diehard sports fan and has been regularly going to MLB, NFL, College, and NHL games for over 30 years. Now, Andy aims to do his part in keeping fellow sports fans fully up to date.

Subscribe

- Never miss a story with notifications

Latest stories