Oregon’s rise in the College Football Playoff rankings feels wrong to many observers. The team moved up three spots after beating a bad Michigan squad at home. The Ducks now sit in a position where their record looks strong on paper.
The Problem With Beating Bad Teams
Winning at home against a weak opponent does not prove a team can win it all. Oregon beat a Michigan team that offered little resistance on the field. The committee rewarded this easy win with a significant boost in the standings. The committee’s decision ignores the fact that Ohio State jumped six spots after a similar result against Northwestern. Both teams beat decent-at-best opponents and received massive rewards for it. The rankings system seems to favor easy wins over tough, proven road battles.
Who Actually Deserves the Top Spots
Undefeated UCLA holds a legitimate argument for a higher ranking than Alabama. The Crimson Tide sits at number three despite two losses, including a 16-point defeat to Tennessee. Yahoo Sports argues that Alabama should be in the top six or seven, not the top three. Georgia remains the clear choice for number one and the pick to win the national championship. Utah also deserves its spot at number two because the team has not lost a game.
A Call For a New System
Every week brings new debates about rankings that seem inconsistent from one Sunday to the next. Some experts suggest doing away with the committee entirely to fix these issues. Returning to the BCS era would use results and a defined process to pick teams.
