The fiercest rivalries in NHL history

0
Devils goalie Martin Brodeur dives and stretches to make a save against the Rangers in a preseason game at Madison Square Garden October 2, 2005 in New York, NY.
Source: Shutterstock

National Hockey League history is defined as much by its bitter blood feuds as it is by its championship dynasties.

The ice has served as a battleground for decades, hosting clashes that transcend simple sport to become matters of regional pride and personal vendetta. From the original expansion era to the modern salary cap age, certain matchups consistently deliver a level of intensity that regular-season games rarely reach.

These are the games where the whistles stay in the pockets, the hits are harder, and the history between the sweaters is felt in every corner of the arena. Fans come prepared, knowing that every shift could write the next chapter in a storied rivalry.

Let’s take a closer look.

Is the Montreal Canadiens and Boston Bruins clash the best?

The rivalry between the Montreal Canadiens and the Boston Bruins is widely considered the gold standard for animosity in professional hockey.

These two Original Six franchises have met in the postseason more than any other pair in league history, clashing in 34 playoff series. The feud is a study in contrasting styles, often pitting Montreal’s historic finesse and speed against the “Big Bad Bruins” and their legendary blue-collar toughness.

While the Canadiens dominated much of the mid-20th century, winning 18 consecutive playoff series against Boston between 1946 and 1987, the tide eventually turned. Modern fans remember the 2011 Eastern Conference quarterfinals as a pivotal moment when the Bruins overcame a 2-0 series deficit to win in seven games, eventually claiming the Stanley Cup.

Every time these teams meet, the weight of nearly a century of bad blood is palpable on the ice.

Boston Bruins alumni Ken Linseman skating during the game.
Source jamieroachDepositphotos

What made the Red Wings and Avalanche feud so violent?

No rivalry in the modern era reached the level of pure, unadulterated hatred seen between the Detroit Red Wings and the Colorado Avalanche in the late 1990s.

This was not just a battle for Western Conference supremacy; it was a years-long war sparked by a specific moment of brutality. In the 1996 Western Conference Finals, Colorado’s Claude Lemieux delivered a hit from behind that shattered the jaw and facial bones of Detroit’s Kris Draper.

The retaliation came nearly a year later on March 26, 1997, in a game now famously known as “Fight Night at the Joe” or “Bloody Wednesday.” The game featured nine separate fights, including a legendary goaltender scrap at center ice between Mike Vernon and Patrick Roy.

Between 1996 and 2002, these two teams combined for five Stanley Cup titles, proving that their animosity was fueled by the fact that they were the two best teams in the world.

Why is the Battle of Alberta so significant?

The “Battle of Alberta” between the Edmonton Oilers and Calgary Flames is a regional civil war that divides an entire province.

Located just three hours apart, these two fanbases have been at each other’s throats since the Flames moved from Atlanta to Calgary in 1980. The 1980s served as the peak of this rivalry, as the two teams were absolute powerhouses that frequently met in high-stakes playoff series.

One of the most infamous moments in the rivalry occurred in 1986 when Oilers defenseman Steve Smith accidentally knocked the puck into his own net, leading to a Calgary series win. This blunder remains a talking point decades later, illustrating how every mistake is magnified in this heated matchup.

The rivalry saw a massive resurgence in 2022 when the two teams met in the postseason for the first time in 31 years, proving the flame of hatred never truly went out.

A close up to a NHL Edmonton Oilers vs Calgary Flames hockey jersey.
Source Shutterstock

How deep do the Toronto and Montreal roots go?

The rivalry between the Toronto Maple Leafs and the Montreal Canadiens is the oldest in the NHL and carries heavy cultural and linguistic weight.

Beyond the sport, this matchup has historically represented the divide between English-speaking and French-speaking Canada. During the Original Six era, these two teams were the only Canadian franchises in the league, meaning they were the primary focus of the entire country’s hockey obsession.

The peak of this animosity occurred in the 1960s when the two clubs essentially traded Stanley Cup championships every year. In 1967, the Maple Leafs defeated the Canadiens in the Final during the centennial year of Canadian Confederation, which remains the last time Toronto hoisted the Cup.

Although they spent years in different conferences, their recent return to the same division has ensured that every “Habs vs. Leafs” night is a national event.

Does the Battle of Pennsylvania still burn bright?

The Philadelphia Flyers and Pittsburgh Penguins have shared a mutual dislike since they both entered the league during the 1967 expansion.

Known as the “Battle of Pennsylvania,” this rivalry is characterized by physical play and high-scoring affairs that often spiral into chaos. The cities themselves share a natural cross-state competition, but the hockey teams have taken it to a level involving legendary figures like Mario Lemieux and Bobby Clarke.

In the modern era, the rivalry has focused on the era of Sidney Crosby and Claude Giroux, highlighted by an insane 2012 playoff series that featured 56 goals in just six games. Pittsburgh has enjoyed more championship success recently, but the Flyers have always taken pride in being the “Broad Street Bullies” who make every visit to Philadelphia a nightmare for the Penguins.

There is no love lost when these two Keystone State teams hit the ice together.

Match between Philadelphia Flyers and Pittsburgh Penguins.
Source mattdotslashdigitalcomDepositphotos

TL;DR

  • The Bruins and Canadiens hold the record for the most playoff meetings in NHL history.
  • The Red Wings and Avalanche rivalry in the 1990s was defined by extreme violence and elite skill.
  • The Battle of Alberta remains one of the most intense regional rivalries due to the proximity of Calgary and Edmonton.
  • Toronto and Montreal represent the oldest and most culturally significant feud in the league.
  • The Battle of Pennsylvania continues to be a high-octane, physical clash for state bragging rights.

Read More:

Greatest Goaltenders In NHL History

Craziest Overtime Moments in NHL History

Legendary Captains Who Inspired Dynasties in NHL

This article was made with AI assistance and human editing.