The New York Yankees cut ties with Luis Gil on Friday, the day teams had to decide which players to keep for 2027. This move ended the contract for the 2024 American League Rookie of the Year. When the deadline passed without contract offers, 44 players, including Gil, became free agents. It is a harsh end for a pitcher who once struck out 171 batters in just 151 and two-thirds innings. The Yankees decided not to take the risk of bringing him back at an arbitration salary projected to be around $2.3 million.
The numbers tell the story of why the front office pulled the trigger. Gil was a star in 2024, but his velocity dropped, his edge faded, and his health failed in the years that followed. He missed the first four months of 2025 because of a lat strain and spent more than three months of 2026 sidelined by right shoulder inflammation. This season, he recorded a 4.61 ERA across five relief outings and four starts, going 1-2. The 28-year-old right-hander walked a major-league-high 77 batters in 2024, despite striking out 171. His command problems became increasingly difficult to overlook as his velocity and strikeout production declined.
Velocity Dropped, Results Followed
Yankees General Manager Brian Cashman explained the struggle during a press conference on Thursday. He noted that Gil tried to find his role in a deep pitching staff. “I think he was finding himself,” Cashman said Thursday of Gil’s season. The Yankees considered whether Gil could be more useful as a reliever than as a starter, but Cashman’s comments reflected uncertainty about where he fit on a deep pitching staff. The club ultimately decided not to commit to another arbitration season while Gil’s effectiveness and role remained uncertain.
Cruz Also Cut Loose
The Yankees did not stop with Gil. They also non-tendered reliever Fernando Cruz, bringing the total to two pitchers lost in one day. Cruz was a key part of the bullpen until a partially torn ulnar collateral ligament shut him down after Aug. 25. Cruz chose to pursue rehabilitation without surgery, hoping to return to the mound in 2027. The Yankees nevertheless decided not to tender him a contract. The 36-year-old had a 3.13 ERA in 61 appearances last season, but his recent health issues made him too risky for a one-year deal.
Both players now join a market that included 183 free agents after the World Series. The Yankees saved money by avoiding arbitration, but they lost two arms who once showed promise. Gil earned $2,162,500 in 2026, but the Yankees declined to offer him a contract for 2027. The team tendered contracts to Clarke Schmidt and five other arbitration-eligible players, signaling that it remains confident in their value despite its own roster and health considerations. According to the New York Post, Gil and Cruz were the only nontenders among the arbitration-eligible Yankees.
